November 21, 2026

The CFR Saw the Measles Crisis Coming in 2019. Here’s How the Warning Played Out

0
The CFR Saw the Measles Crisis Coming in 2019. Here's How the Warning Played Out

Executive Summary: In March 2019, the Council on Foreign Relations warned that a growing anti-vaccination movement threatened decades of progress against measles, including in the United States. Seven years later, the Pan American Health Organization stripped the United States, Mexico, and Bolivia of their measles elimination status. The Americas, the first region in the world to eliminate measles, has reported more than 58,000 cases this year. This analysis looks at what the CFR got right, what it couldn’t have anticipated, and why measles is now a foreign policy problem as much as a domestic one.

On November 17, 2026, the Pan American Health Organization announced that Bolivia, Mexico, and the United States had lost their measles elimination status. Canada lost its status a year earlier. North America no longer has a single country that meets the standard.

None of this came as a surprise to anyone who had been paying attention. In March 2019, the Council on Foreign Relations published a backgrounder by Claire Klobucista titled “Measles and the Threat of the Anti-vaccination Movement.” Its central claim was that vaccine refusal “threatens to undo years of progress” against the disease.

It took seven years for that to happen.

What the CFR Said in 2019

The CFR piece was a backgrounder, not a forecast. It did not predict a date. What it did was identify the mechanism, and the mechanism is what played out.

Its main points:

  • Global measles cases had risen about 30% from 2016 onward.
  • Only about 85% of the world’s infants were getting the first measles dose. The WHO considers 95% necessary to prevent outbreaks.
  • Every U.S. state required certain vaccines for school, but many allowed religious or philosophical exemptions.
  • More cases anywhere meant more risk of measles crossing borders.
  • If the anti-vaccination movement kept growing, the United States could see more outbreaks, even though measles had been considered eliminated there for nearly two decades.

The article also noted that some politicians in Europe and the United States, including at times the U.S. president, had amplified anti-vaccine messaging. In 2019 that was a footnote. By 2026 it was federal policy.

The Near Miss That Should Have Been the Lesson

The CFR published its warning in the middle of a test case.

In late 2018, measles reached Orthodox Jewish communities in New York City and Rockland County. The first outbreak started with a U.S. traveler returning from abroad. By October 1, 2019, the CDC had recorded 1,249 cases nationwide, and three quarters of them were tied to the New York outbreaks.

Elimination status is lost when a single chain of transmission lasts 12 months. New York declared its outbreak over in early October 2019, a few weeks short of that line. The United States kept its status by a matter of weeks.

The response worked because it was aggressive and local. New York City ordered vaccinations in the affected neighborhoods, and the state ended religious exemptions for school vaccine requirements. The lesson health officials drew was simple: elimination survives only if every community stays above the threshold.

What Happened Next

YearEvent
2019U.S. narrowly keeps elimination status after New York outbreaks
2020-2021Pandemic disrupts routine childhood vaccination worldwide
2019-2026U.S. kindergarten MMR coverage falls from 95.2% to 92.4%
January 2025Outbreak begins in Gaines County, Texas
June 2025U.S. halts funding to Gavi, the global vaccine alliance
November 2025Canada loses measles elimination status
January 2026U.S. formally exits the World Health Organization
2026U.S. records 5,838 cases as of November 19, the most since 1991
November 2026PAHO revokes elimination status for the U.S., Mexico, and Bolivia

The decline in coverage was gradual. Nationally, the drop from 95.2% to 92.4% looks small. In practice, the CDC estimates it left roughly 280,000 kindergartners unprotected this school year. The national average also hides local pockets far below it. Those pockets are where every major outbreak since 2019 has started.

A Regional Crisis, Not a National One

The United States is not the epicenter. As of November 13, the Americas had reported 58,213 confirmed measles cases and 82 deaths, compared with 12,596 cases at the same point in 2025.

Guatemala has been hit hardest. Its outbreak was confirmed in January after a religious gathering in December 2025, and by early October it had passed 34,000 cases. Mexico has reported more than 13,500 cases this year. Guatemala and Mexico account for most of the region’s deaths.

This is a setback the hemisphere had already recovered from once. The Americas was the first WHO region to eliminate measles, in 2016. It lost that status when endemic transmission returned in Venezuela and Brazil, and regained it in 2024. Now three countries have lost it in a single announcement.

Genomic data shows how the virus has moved. The strain behind the current wave was first detected in Ontario in 2024. It then appeared in Texas, crossed into Mexico, and has since been identified in outbreaks in at least ten countries in the region.

The Border Runs Both Ways

One detail of the outbreak does not fit the usual political narrative about measles and the southern border.

Mexican health officials traced the Chihuahua outbreak to an unvaccinated 9-year-old boy from a Mennonite community who had visited relatives in Seminole, Texas, at the center of the West Texas outbreak. He brought the virus home, and it spread through his school. Mexico’s epidemic has since reached all 32 of its states. From there, cases traveled to Colombia, Chile, and other countries.

Under the CFR’s 2019 framing, the United States was a country at risk from importations. In 2026 it was the source of one.

The Foreign Policy Dimension

The CFR backgrounder did not examine the national security or foreign policy implications of measles in any depth. Those implications are now hard to miss.

Withdrawal from the WHO

The United States formally left the World Health Organization on January 22, 2026, completing a process that began with an executive order on January 20, 2025. U.S. funding of nearly $280 million ended. The WHO responded by cutting its budget and roughly a quarter of its workforce.

The administration’s case was that the WHO had strayed from its core mission, mishandled COVID-19, and relied too heavily on American money. Critics argue that measles is exactly the kind of cross-border threat the WHO and PAHO exist to coordinate against.

The Gavi decision

In June 2025, Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. announced that the U.S. would stop funding Gavi, the public-private alliance that buys vaccines for children in low-income countries. He said Gavi had “neglected the key issue of vaccine safety.” He cited a 2017 study of a diphtheria-tetanus-pertussis vaccine in Guinea-Bissau, a study other researchers have said has significant flaws. Gavi said it had full confidence in the vaccine. The U.S. had contributed about $8 billion to Gavi since 2001.

The soft-power ledger

Measles control was an American achievement. U.S. funding and leadership helped launch the WHO’s smallpox eradication campaign in 1967. The U.S. was also a central backer of the Expanded Program on Immunization, which took aim at measles and five other childhood diseases starting in 1974. By July 2025, USAID had been dismantled and more than 80% of its programs canceled.

In seven years, the United States went from narrowly defending its own elimination status to seeding an outbreak across its southern border while pulling back from the institutions built to contain one.

The counterargument

Administration officials argue that the U.S. measles problem is domestic and that WHO membership does not vaccinate a single American child. On that narrow point the record backs them up. Canada lost its elimination status in 2025 while it was a full WHO member and a Gavi donor. The CDC has sent $100 million to state health departments for outbreak response. CDC Director Erica Schwartz framed the federal position directly: “The measles elimination designation is not what protects Americans. Vaccination does.”

The weakness of that argument is regional. Measles in Guatemala and Mexico does not stay there, and the U.S. outbreak did not stay in Texas. Elimination in the Americas has always been a collective project, and in 2026 the largest participant stepped back from it.

What the CFR Couldn’t Have Anticipated

The 2019 backgrounder described vaccine hesitancy as a movement pushing against governments. It laid out a debate over whether to tighten mandates. France, Germany, and Italy had moved toward stricter rules, and several U.S. states were trying to make exemptions harder to get.

What it did not anticipate was that a leading voice of vaccine skepticism would end up running federal health policy.

Kennedy spent decades as one of the country’s most prominent critics of vaccines before taking over HHS in 2025. In June 2025 he removed every member of the CDC’s vaccine advisory committee. In January 2026, HHS cut the childhood immunization schedule from 17 universally recommended diseases to 11, without the committee’s usual review. MMR stayed on the list. Kennedy has publicly encouraged measles vaccination while calling it a personal choice.

Kennedy disputes the characterization. At an April 2026 hearing he said, “I have never been anti-vaccine.” He has pointed to Canada and several European countries losing their elimination status, and he blames pandemic-era disruptions to routine care. Part of that defense holds up: coverage was falling before he took office. Critics answer that the worst outbreaks in 35 years happened under the most vaccine-skeptical HHS leadership in the department’s history, at the moment the response most needed a clear federal message.

The Warning Was the Easy Part

The CFR got the diagnosis right in 2019. Vaccine refusal was concentrated in identifiable communities, exemptions were the policy lever, and more measles anywhere meant more measles everywhere. The New York near miss proved the point within months.

Everything that came after was a choice. National coverage slid for six straight years, and the United States walked away from the multilateral system that had kept the hemisphere measles-free. When the test came, federal leadership was divided on whether the problem was the virus or the vaccine.

Regaining elimination status requires stopping transmission for a full year, and given the size of the outbreaks in the region, that could take years. The real question for U.S. policy is whether the country will help rebuild the regional defense or try to wall itself off from a virus that has never respected borders.

Key Takeaways

  • The CFR warned in March 2019 that vaccine refusal threatened to undo decades of progress against measles, including in the United States.
  • The U.S. kept its elimination status in 2019 by only a few weeks, after aggressive local action ended the New York outbreaks.
  • PAHO revoked measles elimination status for the U.S., Mexico, and Bolivia on November 17, 2026, a year after Canada lost its status.
  • The Americas reported more than 58,000 cases and 82 deaths by mid-November 2026, with Guatemala and Mexico hit hardest.
  • Mexico’s epidemic traces back to a child who visited the West Texas outbreak zone, so this time the virus crossed the border southbound.
  • The U.S. left the WHO in January 2026 and stopped funding Gavi in 2025. Supporters cite mission drift and cost, while critics cite weakened regional coordination.
  • Canada lost its status while fully inside the multilateral system, which shows that domestic coverage remains the decisive factor.
  • The CFR did not anticipate that vaccine skepticism would move from the fringe to the head of federal health policy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *